The british museum s refusal to return the 2,500yearold parthenon marbles to greece is based on a single argument. Following a public debate in parliament and its subsequent exoneration of elgin, he sold the marbles to the british government in 1816. Over two centuries later, they remain one of the british museums most. For the last two centuries, the british museum in london has claimed ownership of the elgin marbles without producing documentation that can establish beyond reasonable doubt that lord elgin, a. Rudenstine claims that parliament committed fraud by inserting hunts name into the document, which was later used to legitimize elgin s 1816 sale of his marbles to the british museum at a. Installed in the british museum, london, they are freely accessible and have. The story of the elgin marbles at the british museum the.
May 15, 2015 greece rules out suing british museum over elgin marbles. The parthenon sculptures collected by lord elgin nearly 200 years ago rank amongst the highest achievements of mankind. They further bolster their argument claiming that western culture including britain is a product of greek antiquity, thus the elgin marbles are part of british history as well the british. Exploiting brexit talks will britain lose the elgin marbles. Dr emma payne, 3d imaging conducted courtesy of the trustees of the british museum and acropolis museum antiquity modern pollution fails artwork. Sir henry ellis, british museum, society for the diffusion of useful knowledge great britain publisher. All culture archaeology art books history mythology philosophy photography theater. Lord elgin legally acquired the marbles and britain subsequently legally acquired them from him for the british museum in the absence of unequivocal documentary proof of the actual circumstances under which lord elgin removed the marbles, the legality of britains acquisition of them will always be in doubt. British museum even more vital after brexit, says hartwig fischer. The british museum, in the bloomsbury area of london, united kingdom, is a public institution dedicated to human history, art and culture.
Jan 27, 2019 all culture archaeology art books history mythology philosophy photography theater. To avoid potential data charges from your carrier, we recommend making sure your device is connected to a wifi network before downloading. They were then passed to the british museum, where they are now on display in the purposebuilt duveen gallery. British museum could lend elgin marbles to greece telegraph. Some of the parthenon marbles in the british museum. Part of the parthenon or elgin marbles at the british museum in london.
The british defend their ownership of the marbles based on greeces lack of an adequate museum and the fact that they paid for the pieces mcguigan 2. Short guide sculptures parthenon british museum abebooks. The british museum maintains that elgin was an official diplomat and had acted with the permission of turkish authorities. Read the british museum blog for indepth stories about exhibitions, events and the collection. New book blasts british museum over stolen parthenon marbles. This is a reproduction of a book published before 1923. Keats and the elgin marblesmessage from parthenon the. Should i visit the museum of london or the british museum. Not everything here was acquired by europeans by looting, dr sushma jansari, a curator at the british museum, argued in 2018. Greece may demand britain return parthenons ancient. The director of the british museum has provoked anger by suggesting the removal of the parthenon marbles from greece in the 19th century could be seen as a creative act.
Why the british museum should keep the elgin marbles spiked. British museum lends one of the elgin marbles to the. The cast shows that elgin was not only someone who acquired the works but also by ordering the casts to be made, he greatly helped with preservation. By purchasing books through this website, you support our nonprofit organization. The history of the socalled elgin marbles parthenon. However, the british museum says the marbles were acquired by lord elgin under a legal contract with the ottoman empire, which in maritime terms. Greece would have to acknowledge british museum ownership. Lost in time faces revealed on the elgin marbles ancient.
In 1801 a british nobleman stripped the parthenon of many of its sculptures and took them to england. Why is the british museum still fighting to keep the elgin. The elgin marbles is a 2006 book by american archaeologist dorothy king about the 5th century bce classical greek marble sculptures known as the elgin marbles the book is credited by the sunday times with reigniting the controversy over possession of the elgin marbles by defending the right of the british museum in london to retain them in the face of demands by the government of greece. Dec 11, 2019 the greener area is more like the original marbles than elgins cast is. In 1816 the museum acquired the elgin marbles from thomas bruce, 7th earl of elgin. The british museum has lent one of the elgin marbles to russia. The story of the elgin marbles at the british museum. So we would certainly say that lord elgin had performed a great service in. The british museum disagrees however, claiming that the ancient marbles, which are roughly half of a 160metre frieze that adorned the fifth century bc parthenon temple, were legally acquired by. Sculptures which form part of the elgin marbles taken from the parthenon in athens, greece over 200 years ago on display at the british museum in london, england.
New evidence debunks british museums stance on parthenon. Installed in the british museum, london, they are freely accessible and have had a major influence on generations of artists and scholars. How the parthenon lost its marbles national geographic. And the parliament chose to acquire it and then passed it on the british museum. The remaining part of a sculpture from the west pediment of the parthenon. The parthenon marbles acquired by elgin include some 21 figures from the statuary from the east and west pediments, 15 of an. In contrast, the marbles retained by the british museum were scrubbed with wire brushes in the 1930s by british museum staff in a misguided attempt to make them whiter. The select committee then voted, 82 to 30, to acquire the sculptures. The elgin marbles on display in their own gallery at the british museum the parthenon marbles, sometimes called the elgin marbles, are a series of ancient greek sculptures made from marble. The black head represents an area present in the elgin casts now missing on the original sculptures. Dr emma payne, 3d imaging conducted courtesy of the trustees of the british museum and acropolis museum antiquity the research could become important in the controversy over the elgin marbles.
She said the elgin marbles were acquired legally, with the approval of the ottoman. Parthenon marbles acquisition was legal posted at 2. Installed in the british museum, london, they are freely accessible. They were originally part of the parthenon temple in athens but they were taken by thomas bruce, 7th earl of elgin in the early 1800s. Britain says that lord elgin saved the elgin marbles from destruction and. The marbles were purchased on behalf of the british nation and housed in the british museum. Why the british museum sculptures taken from the parthenon are so controversial. Three years after britons voted in a referendum to leave the eu, british prime minister boris johnson has not yet commented on this escalation to the long standing parthenon marbles situation. British museum simple english wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. The classic collection of marble sculptures from parthenon at the british museum, commonly known as the elgin marbles, has been a vexed source of doubt, appreciation, enthusiasm, disapproval, and. The elgin marbles are still one of the most popular displays at the. Did england commit fraud to keep its elgin marbles. Nov 05, 2019 a british museum spokeswoman confirmed that a stolen goods tour is run by an external guide.
Plus, explore collection online for detailed descriptions of objects. A famous example of this trend was the greek governments demand for the return of the elgin marbles, a request steadfastly refused by the british museum. Today the museum no longer houses collections of natural history, and the books and manuscripts it once held now form part of the independent british library. Putting the return of lord elgins stolen marbles on the brexit. Elgin and phigaleian marbles, volume 1 library of entertaining knowledge the british museum. Its a collection of stone pieces rescuedremoved from the ruins of the ancient greek parthenon in the nineteenth century, and now in demand to be sent back from the british museum to greece. The british museum presents antiquities from all over the world. Apr 04, 2017 lets do a brexit deal with the parthenon marbles. British museum insists elgin marbles were acquired. The british museum s looting problem the venerable museum has given back some stolen iraqi antiquities, but that does not mean its ready to atone for its colonialera sins.
But eu diplomats note that the greek government thinks that the parthenon marbles in the british museum were stolen by lord elgin in the early 1800s. These include the story of the british museum, the british museum reading room and the british museum. British museum is worlds largest receiver of stolen property. Greece rules out suing british museum over elgin marbles. Specifically, greece may demand that the british museum return the parthenon marbles also known as the elgin marbles, named after lord elgin of scotland who removed them more than 200 years ago. The british museum in london has refused to return the sculptures roughly half of a 160m frieze that adorned the fifth century bc monument saying they were acquired by elgin under a legal. Based on a detailed study of both original records and recent discoveries, lord elgin and the marbles is the authoritative historical account of the extraordinary circumstances in which the elgin marbles were acquired, of the tremendous impact which they made on modern appreciation of greekart, and of the bitter reaction of napoleon, byron, and many others to their appropriation. British museum is worlds largest receiver of stolen goods. Facing huge debts, elgin had no choice but to accept.
Robertson was responsible for preparing a report on the reunification of the elgin marbles for the greek government with fellow barrister amal clooney and the late professor norman palmer. A selftouted hellenophile and punctuation freak, new yorker magazine culture columnist mary norris, writing about chinese president xi jinping getting on the bandwagon for the british museum to return to greece the stolen parthenon marbles was caught by surprise earlier this year at an event in wales where she was asked what she thought. Pressure on museums to repatriate artefacts acquired under colonial rule is increasing. The elgin marbles book ancient history encyclopedia. Greece may ask for return of parthenons elgin marbles. How the parthenon lost its marbles history magazine. Controversy over their acquisition by the british museum continues to this day. The acropolis museum allows the parthenon sculptures that are in athens to be appreciated against the backdrop of ancient greek and athenian history. The british museum contains assorted once in a lifetime items including the rosetta stone, the sutton hoo helmet, and the parthenon marbles elgin marbles. Just over 200 years ago, when lord elgin acquired them, the ottomans ruled greece.
Why are the elgin marbles so controversial and everything else. She said the elgin marbles were acquired legally, not as a result of conflict or violence. The real life of the parthenon mad creek books, 2018 traces out this. Keats was observed gazing at them in an uninterruptible rapture, and wrote his famous sonnet on seeing the elgin marbles in response. Updates and additions stemming from research and imaging activities are ongoing, with new content added each week. The british museum tells the story of cultural achievement throughout the world, from the dawn of human history more than two million years ago until the present day. Lord elgin legally acquired the marbles and britain subsequently legally acquired them from him for the british museum. Elgin had taken them from the parthenon in athens, greece several years earlier.
British museum could lend elgin marbles to greece the uk has refused to enter into mediation for the return of the sculptures, but has made tentative overtures towards arranging a loan. Ever since their acquisition by the british nation in 1816, their ownership has been. The trustees of the british museum make the following statement on the museum website in response to arguments for the relocation of the elgin marbles to the acropolis museum. Aug 04, 2018 who rightfully owns the parthenon marbles.
Greece says parthenon marbles return not linked to brexit talks. Greece seeks to bring back ancient sculptures from the uk. Marjorie caygill has published numerous books and articles about the history of the british museum and the collections. However we judge lord elgins original acquisition of the parthenon. The parthenon marbles were takenor rescued, depending on your point of viewfrom the acropolis by lord elgin in the early nineteenth century and now reside in the british museum. Brexit reignites greeces appeal to return stolen parthenon. The elgin marbles also known as the parthenon marbles are a collection of classical greek. Why was lord elgins acquisition of the parthenon marbles. Lets do a brexit deal with the parthenon marbles geoffrey.
The elgin and phigaleian marbles of the classical ages, in the british museum. Prokopis pavlopoulos was speaking in athens where some of the sculptures remain. Its permanent collection of some eight million works is among the largest and most comprehensive in existence, having been widely sourced during the era of the british empire. How brexit has revived controversy over the elgin marbles in britain. A british museum spokeswoman responded to robertsons claims in the opinion piece that lord elgin acquired the marbles legally, with the approval of the ottoman authorities of the day.
This book tells their story, beginning in the fifth century bc when the parthenon was built in athens. Should the parthenon marbles be returned to greece. In 1816, the british museum bought the marbles from elgin. But the british museum s position is the marbles in its collection are legally theirs. Since they went on display in the british museum in 1817, artists, scholars, poets and millions of visitors have stood before them in wonder. Part of the elgin marbles at the british museum in london. He is currently writing a book on the elgin marbles dispute. The british museums looting problem the new republic. The british museums ownership of the statues is only guaranteed within the. New york, jackson, 1833, also by henry ellis and society for the diffusion of useful knowledge great britain page images at hathitrust british museum. The museum of london focuses on londons history from the romans to now. The british museum has vowed to fight off any attempt by the eu to take back the elgin marbles during brexit talks as it said they were acquired completely legally. A british museum spokeswoman confirmed that a stolen goods tour is run by an external guide. British museum is worlds largest receiver of stolen.
British museum rules out returning elgin marbles to. Elgin marbles simple english wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. This book may have occasional imperfections such as missing or blurred pages. Watch our youtube channel for weekly videos from our curators, plus a rich variety of content relating to the museum and its collection. Mar 28, 2015 british museum could lend elgin marbles to greece the uk has refused to enter into mediation for the return of the sculptures, but has made tentative overtures towards arranging a loan. London one of the socalled elgin marbles, the muchdisputed british museum collection of parthenon sculptures and artifacts acquired by lord elgin in athens in the early 19th century, has been sent out of england for the first time.
The elgin and phigaleian marbles in in the british museum. After all, the british museum regularly loans pieces from its collection to other museums around the world. These sculptures, or elgin marbles as they are sometimes called, were acquired from lord elgin by the british museum in 1816, and have been admired here since a remarkable history that is reflected in this unique ornament. The director of the british museum has appeared to rule out returning the elgin marbles to greece after its government demanded britain open negotiations over their return last year. Help us improve our records by sharing your corrections or suggestions. The objects were removed from the parthenon at athens and from other ancient buildings and shipped to england by arrangement of thomas. Greece could be able to request the return of the elgin marbles from the uk as part of.
But british museum chief said elgin marbles were acquired completely legally hartwig fischer, the director of the british museum the british museum has vowed to fight off any attempt by the eu to take back the elgin marbles during brexit talks as it said they were acquired completely legally. Greek president demands uk return parthenon marbles from. But lord duveen, the art dealer who sponsored the gallery, had them heavily restored. Apr 06, 2014 its permanent collection of some eight million works is among the largest and most comprehensive in existence, having been widely sourced during the era of the british empire. The elgin marbles are a source of controversy between modern britain and greece. This information is published from the museum s collection database. The elgin marbles, as they became known, became an instant phenomenon when they went on view the following year. The marble sculptures, which formerly decorated the parthenon on the acropolis, have been on display at the museum since 1817. Many people disagreed with the way elgin took them from greece. Some, including tate modern, are now embracing procters events. Why the british museum should keep the elgin marbles. Before it releases any of its share of other peoples cultural heritage, the british museum could mount an exhibition the spoils of empire.
A greek request to borrow the elgin marbles from the british museum would only be considered if greece acknowledges british ownership of the sculptures, the museum said on tuesday. After more than 250 years, the museum remained a symbol of the renaissance eras thirst for knowledge, and one of the worlds leading repositories for the history of human civilization. And the british opposition labor leader jeremy corbyn has said he too is in favor of returning the marbles to greece. The parthenon sculptures in the british museum british.
390 1210 27 1448 780 1030 843 535 1387 378 256 959 209 1231 560 1356 1046 585 1375 23 382 194 1037 1082 911 1334 250 439 826 3 718 1176 454 251 482 986 753 1046 508 1163 737 909 273 30 180 498